November 16, 2026

Section 174A and a European engineer: the real US cost

Domestic R&E is deductible again under 174A; work done in Europe still amortizes over 15 years. What that does to a European engineer's after-tax cost.

Cost

Guide

Section 174 foreign research is still deducted over 15 years, while section 174A makes US research deductible again in the year you pay it. A profitable company pays about 12% more after tax on a European engineer. A startup whose revenue roughly matches its engineering spend can owe tax with no cash profit, and one with clear losses barely notices. We'd compare loaded cost first, then ask a CPA about location.

Does 174A make my European engineers deductible too?

No. Section 174A covers domestic research only, and work done in Europe stays under section 174.

Domestic: deducted in the year you pay

Section 174A of the tax code lets you deduct domestic research and experimental spending in the year it's paid, for tax years that begin after 31 December 2024.

Foreign: spread over 15 years

Section 174 spreads foreign research evenly over 15 years, starting from the midpoint of the year you pay. The midpoint is the first day of the seventh month, so year one gets only half a year of deduction. Research counts as foreign when it's conducted outside the US, Puerto Rico or a US possession.

The total deduction is the same as for a US engineer, only later. Two details make it harsher than it sounds. If you retire or abandon the product, the unamortized cost stays on the schedule instead of becoming a deduction. And software development counts as research under section 174(c)(3), so engineers writing your product code are in scope, not only lab-style R&D.

Does it matter where my engineer sits or who employs them?

The IRS's Notice 2023-63 says to look to where the research is performed. Who pays, and from which country, doesn't change that.

A foreign vendor or contractor

The notice treats research done by another party as yours when it's done "at the taxpayer's order and risk." In plain words, you pay for the work and own the result, so the research counts as yours, and where it's done decides whether it's foreign. It also counts contract employees and independent contractors who perform, supervise or directly support research as labor costs. A European vendor building your product therefore points to foreign research for you, the US payer.

Treat that as a working assumption. Notice 2023-63 is interim guidance written for section 174 as it stood before 2025, and Rev. Proc. 2026-32 still lets taxpayers rely on it. The open questions are in the CPA checklist below.

Mixed teams

If one engineer sits in Berlin and another in Austin on the same product, you have two treatments. Split time and cost by where the work happens. The UK runs a different overseas rule, and how the UK treats the same question is worth a read if you also have UK entities.

What does one European engineer cost after tax?

About 12% more than the same spend in the US, for a company that would have used every deduction in the year paid. Here's the illustration. We assume €75 an hour, the mid-point of HighCircl's published €45-105 band, for 2,112 hours (176 a month for 12 months), so €158,400. Tax is the 21% federal corporate rate under section 11(b), with no state tax and no currency conversion, and the same spend on both sides. Swap in your own US loaded cost, and see software development team cost in Europe for the layers around the rate.

EngineerYear-1 deductionYear-1 tax savedFully deducted
US (section 174A)€158,400€33,264Year 1
European (section 174)€5,280€1,109Year 16

The European engineer gets half a year of deduction in year one, a full fifteenth in each of years two to 15, and the last half-year in year 16. Hire steadily for 16 years and the yearly foreign deduction finally matches the yearly spend.

Whether that costs you anything depends on what a euro of tax saved today is worth against one saved later. At a 10% discount rate (use your own), the spread-out deductions are worth about 53% of the immediate ones. The €33,264 saving becomes roughly €17,700, a gap of about €15,600. After tax, the European engineer costs about €140,700 against €125,100.

When does it barely matter?

Clear losses

For a company with no taxable income, the deduction arrives later rather than being lost. The US engineer would add €158,400 to your net operating loss in year one and the European engineer adds €5,280. Under section 172, a net operating loss carries forward without a year limit but offsets at most 80% of later taxable income. A startup that won't pay tax for years loses very little today.

Loss-making on cash, taxable on paper

Take revenue of €158,400 and engineer spend of €158,400, nothing else. With a US engineer, taxable income is zero. With a European one, taxable income in year one is €153,120 and the tax is about €32,200 on a business with no cash profit. When revenue tracks engineering spend, "loss-making" on cash doesn't mean loss-making for tax.

What should I do before the 2026 return?

  1. Split engineering cost by where the work is done, separately for employees and vendors.
  2. Keep time records for anyone who splits their time between locations.
  3. Keep contracts that show who performs the work, who directs it and who carries the risk.
  4. Record location as it actually is. The location test follows the facts, not the paperwork.
  5. Ask your CPA whether a European vendor counts as foreign research under the order-and-risk test.
  6. Ask how a European subsidiary that pays the engineer is treated.
  7. Ask how a vendor's margin is treated.
  8. Ask whether Notice 2023-63 still governs years after 2024 until regulations arrive, and how Treasury will handle contract research after 174A.

No primary guidance yet answers questions 6 to 8, so expect your CPA to give a judgment, not a citation. Book accounting is a separate question, covered in capitalized software costs in your books.

What this means for your hiring budget

Price the hire on loaded cost first. Then add the tax layer only for roles where you expect taxable income in the next few years, and treat it as a timing adjustment, not a reason to stay domestic.

Our rule of thumb: if you're profitable, a European cost needs to come in about 11% under the US cost before tax to break even after tax, at a 10% discount rate. That's the same gap seen from the price side. If you have clear losses, ignore it until profits get close.

Whoever owns the FY27 hiring budget, usually the finance lead, should take the CPA questions in before the 2026 return closes, because the answers decide which engineers sit on the foreign schedule. For the other layers of cost to add to this one, start with our software development cost guides.

Hiring European engineers through HighCircl

If you want a real European rate to run this comparison on, ours is published. HighCircl places senior engineers at €45-105 an hour, a pay-plus-margin rate where the 20% margin is capped and applied on top of what the engineer earns. That gives you a visible number to put in the first column of your comparison before you add any tax timing.

FAQ

Is a European engineer deductible under section 174A?

No. Section 174A covers domestic research only. Work done outside the US, Puerto Rico or a US possession stays under section 174 and is amortized over 15 years.

How is the foreign deduction spread?

Ratably over 15 years from the midpoint of the year you pay. In the €158,400 illustration, that's €5,280 in year one, €10,560 a year in years two to 15, and €5,280 in year 16.

Does a loss-making startup lose the deduction?

No. It still deducts over time but builds a smaller net operating loss early on. Those losses carry forward without a year limit and offset at most 80% of later taxable income.

Does paying a European vendor or contractor count as foreign research?

Where the work is done decides, and research by another party at your order and risk follows the same principles. That points to foreign research for you, but the guidance is interim, so confirm it with a CPA.

What does 15-year amortization cost in practice?

About 12% more after tax on the same spend, at a 10% discount rate and 21% tax, for a company that would have used the deduction at once. At a 5% discount rate it's about 8%. Both are illustrations, so use your own rate.

Sources

Share this article

Author Image

HighCircl Editorial Team

The HighCircl editorial team writes about hiring software engineers, nearshore development, and engineering team building. Our articles draw on direct experience sourcing and placing senior developers across Poland, Hungary, Slovakia, Serbia, Slovenia, Romania, and Spain — and on candid conversations with the CTOs and engineering leads who hire them.

HighCircl is a nearshore engineering network that delivers matched candidate shortlists in 72 hours. Every piece of content we publish is informed by real engagement data: actual developer rates, real hiring timelines, and what separates engineering teams that scale cleanly from those that stall.

Take Me to the Experts

Access our network of industry-leading software engineers.

Start Now